Skip to Content
Advertisement
History

The Amateur Archaeologist Who Found the Wrong Troy

Heinrich Schliemann was a thousand years off the mark—but he did still make meaningful discoveries

The Death of Patroclus – Illustration from page 265 of ‘The Iliad of Homer. Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

Three millennia ago, the Greek bard Homer spun an epic yarn that became “the original action film.” The Iliad recounted the Trojan War, a key event in Greek mythology—some readers took this tale literally, and by the 19th century, a growing number of amateur archaeologists became determined to hunt down real-life Troy.

Featured Video

These dogged fans included the German businessman Heinrich Schliemann, born on this day in 1822. At the time, the remnants of Troy were suspected to lie in a region called the Troad in what’s now Turkey. In 1868, Schliemann visited the Troad “with Homer in one hand and a spade in the other,” according to the British Museum. Schliemann teamed up with Frank Calvert, a British amateur archaeologist, to dig into a hill in the area called Hissarlik. There, Calvert claimed he had found artifacts tied to ancient Troy, but he needed Schliemann’s financial support.

UNBURIED TEASURES: Schliemann’s wife, Sophia, donning jewelry that he excavated from the Troy site. Photo by Elizabeth Simpson/Wikimedia Commons.

The two began an illegal excavation of Hissarlik in 1870, before they received a permit in 1871. Over the next few years, the team excavated a large trench into this hill to reach a layer around 56 feet deep, damaging other historical structures in the process. They believed this spot contained remnants connected to Homer’s epic.

Advertisement

Schliemann and Calvert’s search didn’t come up totally empty: They encountered exciting artifacts including jewelry and silver and gold vessels, which Schliemann called “Priam’s Treasure” in reference to the king of Troy from the Iliad. He thought this loot, consisting of thousands of items, also included the jewels of Helen. Schliemann even smuggled these finds to Athens.

Read more: “The Beloved Mesolithic Girl

In reality, the eager explorers missed the mark. Later research suggested that the Trojan War from the Iliad—if it actually happened as Homer described it—would date back to more than a millennium later than the evidence unearthed by Schliemann and Calvert. The region has been inhabited for around 8,000 years, and archaeologists have divided the settlements found at Troy over time into multiple layers. Schliemann and Calvert had actually found items from a period called Troy II, which is estimated to have spanned 2550 to 2300 B.C., when the village was modestly sized yet thriving.

By around 1750 B.C., during the late Bronze Age, Troy rose to local prominence within its area of the Hittite Empire and might have attracted conflict with the jealous Greeks—a brawl that could have constituted the Trojan War.

Advertisement

Not long after encountering his Troy trove, Schliemann also checked out what he believed to be the settings of Homer’s tales in the Aegean. At the site of Mycenae, an ancient Greek civilization, he dug up royal tombs and found a funerary mask that he thought belonged to the mythical king Agamemnon, for example.

Today, Schliemann is remembered for his ethically questionable research tactics and his contribution to the discovery of one of Europe’s earliest advanced civilizations, the Bronze Age Mycenaean culture. Schliemann might have scoured in vain for Homer’s Troy, but his digs did lay the foundation for our current grasp of ancient Greece. 

Enjoying  Nautilus? Subscribe to our free newsletter.

Lead image: Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement
Advertisement

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from History

Explore History

How Three Students Designed an Atomic Bomb

A top-secret 1960s project tasked physics postdocs with building The Bomb

March 5, 2026

The Thrill of Science in 2042

A science historian explains how science got its groove back. A fictional dispatch from the future.

February 27, 2026

How Energy Politics Played Out on the White House Roof

The quick removal of Jimmy Carter’s futuristic solar panels echoes more recent feuds over renewables

February 20, 2026

The Missing Pieces of the Donner Party Narrative

People have only recently included Indigenous voices in the story

February 19, 2026

Space Age Technology Reveals Secrets of Bronze Age Sword

Scientists in Berlin performed a battery of tests on a 3,400-year-old weapon

February 18, 2026

The Retiree Who Inspired the Wright Brothers to Take Flight

Octave Chanute’s engineering prowess laid the foundation for powered planes

February 18, 2026